Good Samaritan Laws: What’s Your Opinion?

Below are addresses for more editorials about Good Samaritan laws.  Some of them discuss laws which protect Good Samaritans from prosecution, and some discuss laws which would prosecute if one does NOT help.

You may go directly to each link, but this will cause you to leave the main page.  

Instead, highlight, right click, and select OPEN LINK IN NEW TAB.

KEEP A TAB OPEN FOR EACH ARTICLE AND FLIP BACK AND FORTH BETWEEN THEM TO COMPARE THEM.

 

ASSIGNMENT

to be recorded in your journal (include the date, please):

I.  FIRST, make a list of the articles by title.  After each title, answer each of the following about the article, in complete sentences:

1. Does the article state an opinion, or is it informational?

2. Is the article a) about laws which protect Samaritans, b) laws which prosecute people for not helping, or c) both?

II. NEXT, create a MAIN IDEA – DETAIL – DETAIL – DETAIL block (three details) for any TWO of the links below, with the title of the article on top.  Pick the two articles which best help you support your opinion about Good Samaritan laws.

Make sure your details are pieces of evidence the authors have used to support his or her MAIN IDEA (his or her opinion).

III. THEN, think about what you read today, together with the two editorials we read as a class, “If Law Doesn’t Make Us . . .” and “Good Samaritans USA . . .”.

IV. FINALLY, write a final one to three paragraph paper on binder paper.  Before you write, consider the evidence each writer provided.

ANSWER:  

Do you believe we should have Good Samaritan laws?  If so, what kind – laws which protect helpers, laws which prosecute for not helping, or both?  

Give reasons for your opinion by using specific evidence you have gathered from the articles.

 

ARTICLES

http://community.seattletimes.nwsource.com/archive/?date=20000215&slug=4004934

http://community.seattletimes.nwsource.com/archive/?date=20010211&slug=goodsam11m

http://reason.com/blog/2012/06/20/good-samaritan-laws-that-protect-people

http://www.divinecaroline.com/33/74377-help-wanted-samaritan-laws

 

Omaira Sanchez: A Real Girl, Not a Character

Below is an article about Omaira Sanchez, the young Colombian girl upon whom the character Azucena is based in “And of Clay Are We Created.”  After you have read it, use the paragraph slide to help you answer:

What are three main differences between “And of Clay Are We Created” and “Ill-Equipped Rescuers”?  Include a topic sentence, three examples of differences, and a concluding sentence.

 

“Ill-Equipped Rescuers Dig Out Volcano Victims; Aid Slow to Reach Colombian Town”
Bradley Graham


–from The Washington Post
November 16, 1985

In this Washington Post newspaper article, the reporter relates what he hears and sees in Armero, Colombia, two days after the eruption of Mount Ruiz. Much of the article gives details of the desperate situation in and around the
stricken village. The article also relates the stories of two survivors—a farmer who is finally pulled from under his collapsed house and a young girl who is buried up to her neck in mud. It  was this girl, Omaira Sanchez, who inspired Allende to write the story.


ARMERO, Colombia, Nov. 15, 1985—From beneath the rubble of what was Armero, now a mass of broken concrete slabs and twisted corrugated metal, lay scattered belongings and crushed bodies buried under brown watery slush, came the cries of survivors who had been alive two days after a volcanic eruption caused by a flood of mud that swallowed this town.

But few were here to save them. Officials in Bogota, who had declared a national emergency after the eruption Wednesday of Nevado del Ruiz volcano, reported that aid had begun to arrive from the United States, Europe, and international agencies. But only a tinyamount of material and a small number of volunteers have arrived so far to this main scene of disaster.

Relief workers, laboring in hot, humid weather amid the rising stench of spoiled food and decomposing bodies, said there was a desperate shortage of supplies and personnel. As they worked, more tremors and rumbles were
felt from the volcano.

Government and relief officials estimated that as many as 20,000 people may have died in the disaster, and thousands more have been injured.  But those on the scene stressed that a complete casualty count would not be possible
for a long time.

Walter Cotte of the Red Cross said many of the dead were buried in mass graves without being photographed or fingerprinted. One relief official said it would probably be necessary to declare Armero “holy ground,” leaving many of the dead buried where they died. Hastily constructed tent hospitals were set up in the nearby towns of
Mariquita, Lerida, and Guayabal, civil defense officials said, but there were few helicopters to carry the victims there, and no roads were passable in the narrow Andean valleys near Armero. “We don‘t have the help we need,” said Raul Alferez, who is in charge of the Red Cross medical unit here. “We need people, we need equipment, but we have next to nothing.”

The magnitude of what has to be done is overwhelming. What was once a picturesque country city of 25,000 people is now a mangled mass of junk and corpses.

In the low hills above the city, several hundred people have camped in makeshift huts with tin roofs. They are the lucky ones, those who managed somehow to escape the waves of hot mud and debris that swept through Armero. But they were not being evacuated. Relief officials said priority for seats in the nine or ten helicopters ferrying people to and from the disaster site was given to the injured.

On the northwest side of Armero, several bulldozers were pushing back the mud, trying to open a road into the town. But it could be days before emergency land vehicles can reach here. The Red Cross has set up a tent and evacuation area in a clearing several hundred yards from where the mud stopped. Only five medics and fifteen volunteers made up the Red Cross team today, according to Alferez. Also helping in the rescue effort here were about ten blue-suited Air
Force members and Defense workers.

Yesterday, emergency teams pulled survivors off the roofs and trees where they had climbed to escape the avalanche. Today, the rescuers searched for those buried alive in the mud. Alferez estimated that 1,000 people could be trapped alive in the city‘s ruins. An Argentine medic participating in the relief effort, 23-yearold Alejandro Jimenez, guessed that there could be 2,000.

As of early this afternoon, Alferez, who was not keeping exact records, said about 65 injured survivors had been found and flown out today. But there is no organization, no plan, to search for the living. It is a hit-or-miss operation.
Survivors have been located most often when their screams or cries were heard by passersby. Once survivors are found, the process of freeing them is a lengthy, arduous effort.

One team of workers spent much of this morning trying to pry a 34-year-old man from his collapsed house while, a few yards away, another team chest-deep in water sought desperately to lift to safety a 13-year-old girl whose feet were pinned by fallen concrete.

The man, Efrain Gomez Primo, a peanut farmer and candy vendor, was stuck under his collapsed house. He talked about his ordeal as rescue workers hacked away with machetes at the boards that imprisoned him.

He said the walls of his house fell in Wednesday night as he was trying to flee the raging current. After the volcanic storm had subsided, he said, he started screaming for help. His brother found him at 6:30 yesterday morning and told him not to worry, that the Red Cross, Civil Defense, and Army were on their way. The brother never returned.

A Civil Defense worker who arrived soon afterward lacked the necessary tools and left. It was not until late this morning that a rescue squad arrived.  By then, a middle-aged woman, who had been caught in the wreckage with him and was in great pain through last night, had died. Her corpse lay facing up on a sheet of tin.

“I‘m half dead,” he said, as the effort to free him began. No one had given him anything to eat or drink for more than 36 hours. Gasping for air, he exclaimed, “I can barely breathe.”

When he was finally pried loose and carried to the evacuation zone, medics had no splint for Gomez‘s broken right leg. They tied a strip of cardboard around it.

Just a few yards from Gomez was the girl, Omayra Sanchez. She had been found just after dawn yesterday by an Air Force officer working in the rescue campaign.  The worst problem was how to pry loose the stiff arms of the girl‘s dead
aunt, who had grasped the child the night of the tragedy.

Sanchez said the waters of the ravaging Lagunilla River had prevented her aunt from opening the door of their house. All during that stormy night, before she died, the aunt kept apologizing for not having managed to rush the family to freedom, the niece recalled.

The girl‘s eyes were bright red and swollen. When rescue workers called for an anesthetic, there was none.
She asked for cookies, but there were none of those either. Somehow the girl managed to stay calm and lucid, closing her eyes in pain at times, breaking into tears at other moments.

She would wrap her hands around the neck of a rescue worker standing in the water in front of her and try, with all her might, to tear herself free of whatever was keeping her feet pinned down. But she could not budge.

Workers dug around her, lifting out huge blocks of broken concrete. Rescuers feared that rising water would drown the girl if they couldn‘t get her out soon. Her head was just above the water line.

Watching the desperate attempts to save the girl, Alferez, the Red Cross chief, shook his head in despair.
“This makes one feel useless,” he said. “What can we do?”

End